Islay – Page 4 – Horny Pony

Horny Pony is taking a break. Any orders made now will not be sent until 28th July

FREE SHIPPING WITH ORDERS OVER $200

Octomore 14.2 57.7%ABV 30ml

Octomore 14.2 57.7%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $21.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $21.00 AUD
Unit price per
Makes my Heart Wreck Once Again (Ardbeg) 14y/o 2009 East Village Whisky Co. 49.3%ABV 30ml

Makes my Heart Wreck Once Again (Ardbeg) 14y/o 2009 East Village Whisky Co. 49.3%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $25.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $25.00 AUD
Unit price per
Secret Islay 10y/o PX Cask East Village Whisky Co. 53.2%ABV 30ml

Secret Islay 10y/o PX Cask East Village Whisky Co. 53.2%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $18.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $18.00 AUD
Unit price per
Port Charlotte 2012 SC:01 55.2%ABV 30ml

Sold out

Port Charlotte 2012 SC:01 55.2%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $21.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $21.00 AUD
Unit price per

Sold out
Bunnahabhain (Staoisha) 9y/o 2013 The Whisky Jury 57.3%ABV 30ml

Sold out

Bunnahabhain (Staoisha) 9y/o 2013 The Whisky Jury 57.3%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $18.50 AUD

Regular price Sale price $18.50 AUD
Unit price per

Sold out
Ardbeg 13y/o "Makes My Heart Wreck" East Village Whisky Co. 54.4%ABV 30ml

Ardbeg 13y/o "Makes My Heart Wreck" East Village Whisky Co. 54.4%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $33.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $33.00 AUD
Unit price per
Lagavulin 12y/o Special Release 2022 57.3%ABV 30ml

Sold out

Lagavulin 12y/o Special Release 2022 57.3%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $15.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $15.00 AUD
Unit price per

Sold out
Kilchoman Quarter Cask Cask Strength 2016 Release 56.9%ABV 30ml

Kilchoman Quarter Cask Cask Strength 2016 Release 56.9%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $16.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $16.00 AUD
Unit price per
Kilchoman Red Wine Cask 2017 Release 50%ABV 30ml

Kilchoman Red Wine Cask 2017 Release 50%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $16.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $16.00 AUD
Unit price per
Kilchoman Madeira Cask 1st release 2015 50%ABV 30ml

Kilchoman Madeira Cask 1st release 2015 50%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $16.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $16.00 AUD
Unit price per
Laphroaig 10y/o Cask Strength Batch 12 60.1%ABV 30ml

Sold out

Laphroaig 10y/o Cask Strength Batch 12 60.1%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $14.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $14.00 AUD
Unit price per

Sold out
Kilchoman Fino Sherry Cask Matured 2023 50%ABV 30ml

Kilchoman Fino Sherry Cask Matured 2023 50%ABV 30ml

1 review

1 total reviews

Regular price $14.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $14.00 AUD
Unit price per
Kilchoman Cognac Cask Matured 2023 50%ABV 30ml

Kilchoman Cognac Cask Matured 2023 50%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $14.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $14.00 AUD
Unit price per
Ardbeg 13y/o Anthology 'The Harpy's Tale 46%ABV 30ml

Ardbeg 13y/o Anthology 'The Harpy's Tale 46%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $20.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $20.00 AUD
Unit price per
Bunnahabhain 8y/o North Star Oak Barrel Exclusive 49.9%ABV 30ml

Bunnahabhain 8y/o North Star Oak Barrel Exclusive 49.9%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $14.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $14.00 AUD
Unit price per
Ardbeg BizzarreBQ 50.9%abv 30ml

Ardbeg BizzarreBQ 50.9%abv 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $12.50 AUD

Regular price Sale price $12.50 AUD
Unit price per
Bruichladdich 16y/o Rock’ndaal 02.1 Feis Ile 2023 50%ABV 30ml

Bruichladdich 16y/o Rock’ndaal 02.1 Feis Ile 2023 50%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $32.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $32.00 AUD
Unit price per
Caol Ila 8y/o SMWS 'Throw the Cork Away!' Islay Whisky Festival 2022 58.4%ABV 30ML

Sold out

Caol Ila 8y/o SMWS 'Throw the Cork Away!' Islay Whisky Festival 2022 58.4%ABV 30ML

No reviews

Regular price $17.50 AUD

Regular price Sale price $17.50 AUD
Unit price per

Sold out
Ardbeg Ardcore Limited Release 46%ABV 30ml

Ardbeg Ardcore Limited Release 46%ABV 30ml

1 review

1 total reviews

Regular price $16.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $16.00 AUD
Unit price per
Ardbeg Heavy Vapours Committee Bottling 50.2%ABV 30ml

Ardbeg Heavy Vapours Committee Bottling 50.2%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $20.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $20.00 AUD
Unit price per

Let customers speak for us

from 193 reviews

Thanks!

Had what I needed, fast delivery and thanks for the Sprinbank sample!! 🙏

Anonymous

07/23/2026

Great experience

Great experience, much recommend 👌

Bryce Cordon

07/15/2026

Great OB and IB Scotch whisky range.

Fantastic range of reasonably priced unique OB and small batch IB Scotch whiskies.

Ben Hutchins

06/27/2026

Delicious!!

It’s everything you look for, layered, spiced, fresh and melts in your mouth!!

Tyler Marschke

06/01/2026

Old Islay 21y/o (Bowmore) Decadent Drinks 55%ABV 15ml / 30ml

Old Islay 21y/o (Bowmore) Decadent Drinks 55%ABV 15ml / 30ml

Spirit Thief Distillation Co. 'Nearly New York Sour' Whisky in Isolation 53%abv 30ml

Justin Wright

04/28/2026

Spirit Thief Distillation Co. 'Nearly New York Sour' Whisky in Isolation 53%abv 30ml

Spirit Thief Distillation Co. 'Nearly New York Sour' Whisky in Isolation 53%abv 30ml

Springbank Magic

Outstanding! Thanks Horny Pony for giving the average whisky enthusiast a chance to taste bottles that we can't get our hands on.

damien simpson

01/22/2026

Springbank 12y/o Cask Strength Batch 22 (2021) 55.4%ABV 30ml

Springbank 12y/o Cask Strength Batch 22 (2021) 55.4%ABV 30ml

Macallan bottled the way it should be!

The nose is outstanding and the palate is excellent, very enjoyable dram!

damien simpson

01/22/2026

Macallan 16y/o Speyside 'M' 100° Proof Edition#15 Signatory Vintage 57.1%ABV 30ml

Macallan 16y/o Speyside 'M' 100° Proof Edition#15 Signatory Vintage 57.1%ABV 30ml

Glendronach 27y/o 1993 Oloroso Sherry Puncheon #7274 54.2%ABV 15ml / 30ml

Gorgi Micevski

12/27/2025

Glendronach 27y/o 1993 Oloroso Sherry Puncheon #7274 54.2%ABV 15ml / 30ml

Glendronach 27y/o 1993 Oloroso Sherry Puncheon #7274 54.2%ABV 15ml / 30ml

Great Laph batch!

This one just sings with a little water, so sweet and smoky!

Wade

11/06/2025

Laphroaig 10y/o Cask Strength Batch 13 57.9%ABV 30ml

Laphroaig 10y/o Cask Strength Batch 13 57.9%ABV 30ml

How whisky should be

This one SLAPS, sooooo good!!

Wade

11/06/2025

Kildalton (Ardbeg) 14y/o Islay Sponge Part 3 60%ABV 30ml

Kildalton (Ardbeg) 14y/o Islay Sponge Part 3 60%ABV 30ml

Serious complexity

One of the best aussie whiskies Ive tried. A real coffee and dark chocolate profile and little alcohol heat with a real chewy texture.

Laurence Ryan

11/03/2025

Waubs Harbour Yeast Cask Limited Release 51.8%ABV 30ml

Waubs Harbour Yeast Cask Limited Release 51.8%ABV 30ml

Sherry Bomb that stands up to global peers

In classic Australian style, this whisky has absolutely rippled flavour out of its cask. However, while I was expecting spiky youth in the spirit and the abv, it drinks with a maturity and ease that belies these facts. I have since bought two bottles. Absolutely delicious and as good, if not better, than it’s Scotch peers

Michael C

10/18/2025

Spring Bay ‘The Beast’ 70.9%ABV 15ml/30ml

Spring Bay ‘The Beast’ 70.9%ABV 15ml/30ml

Thick and juicy!

Will always love this drop, it’s one of the more syrupy Macallans I’ve tried and definitely smooth and full of flavour!

Tyler Marschke

09/06/2025

Speyside 15y/o 2009 (Macallan) 1st Fill & Refill Sherry Butts Small Batch #18 Signatory Vintage 48.2%abv 30ml

Speyside 15y/o 2009 (Macallan) 1st Fill & Refill Sherry Butts Small Batch #18 Signatory Vintage 48.2%abv 30ml

Sweet and sensitive, dry with summer fruits.

Lovely drop this, I revisit it when I can. Not a power punch but quality liquid and beautiful flavour!

Tyler Marschke

09/06/2025

Glenfiddich Snow Phoenix 47.6%ABV 15ml / 30ml

Glenfiddich Snow Phoenix 47.6%ABV 15ml / 30ml

Ben Nevis 10y/o Australian Whisky Icons - The Elysian Bar The WhiskySponge 57.1%ABV 30ml

Christopher O'Hara

07/26/2025

Ben Nevis 10y/o Australian Whisky Icons - The Elysian Bar The WhiskySponge 57.1%ABV 30ml

Ben Nevis 10y/o Australian Whisky Icons - The Elysian Bar The WhiskySponge 57.1%ABV 30ml