Islay – Page 2 – Horny Pony

FREE SHIPPING WITH ORDERS OVER $250

Lagavulin Islay Jazz Festival 2017 57.6% 30ml

Lagavulin Islay Jazz Festival 2017 57.6% 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $30.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $30.00 AUD
Unit price per
Bruichladdich 'Classic Laddie' 50%ABV 30ml

Bruichladdich 'Classic Laddie' 50%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $10.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $10.00 AUD
Unit price per
An Islay Distillery 30y/o Marriage of Casks Single Malts of Scotland 47.5%ABV 30ml

An Islay Distillery 30y/o Marriage of Casks Single Malts of Scotland 47.5%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price From $24.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price From $24.00 AUD
Unit price per
Bunnahabhain Staoisha 2013 1st Fill PX Sherry Hogshead Germany exclusive Whisky Sponge 53.8%abv 30ml

Bunnahabhain Staoisha 2013 1st Fill PX Sherry Hogshead Germany exclusive Whisky Sponge 53.8%abv 30ml

1 review

1 total reviews

Regular price $24.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $24.00 AUD
Unit price per
Bruichladdich 2012 Red Bordeaux Cask East Village Whisky Co. 52.7%ABV 30ml

Bruichladdich 2012 Red Bordeaux Cask East Village Whisky Co. 52.7%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $28.50 AUD

Regular price Sale price $28.50 AUD
Unit price per
Bruichladdich 8y/o 2014 Allier 2nd Fill Cask#1588 Micro Provenance NZ Exclusive 62.9%Abv 30ml

Bruichladdich 8y/o 2014 Allier 2nd Fill Cask#1588 Micro Provenance NZ Exclusive 62.9%Abv 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $20.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $20.00 AUD
Unit price per
Bunnahabhain 14y/o First Fill Sherry Cask#358 Gordon & MacPhail 57.6%abv 30ml

Bunnahabhain 14y/o First Fill Sherry Cask#358 Gordon & MacPhail 57.6%abv 30ml

1 review

1 total reviews

Regular price $24.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $24.00 AUD
Unit price per
Lagavulin 16y/o 1999 Distillers Edition 43% 30ml

Lagavulin 16y/o 1999 Distillers Edition 43% 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $18.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $18.00 AUD
Unit price per
Kilchoman 6y/o Port Cask (2024) 50%ABV 30ml

Kilchoman 6y/o Port Cask (2024) 50%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $13.50 AUD

Regular price Sale price $13.50 AUD
Unit price per
Kilchoman 100% Islay 14th Edition 50%ABV 30ml

Kilchoman 100% Islay 14th Edition 50%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $13.50 AUD

Regular price Sale price $13.50 AUD
Unit price per
Caol Ila 13y/o Islay Sponge No. 6 53%ABV 30ml

Caol Ila 13y/o Islay Sponge No. 6 53%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $24.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $24.00 AUD
Unit price per
Caol Ila 13y/o 2009 'Aila Col' The Whisky Jury 56.3%ABV 30ml

Caol Ila 13y/o 2009 'Aila Col' The Whisky Jury 56.3%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $19.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $19.00 AUD
Unit price per
Ardbeg Alligator (2011) 51.2%ABV 30ml

Ardbeg Alligator (2011) 51.2%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price From $25.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price From $25.00 AUD
Unit price per
Bowmore 25y/o 1997 PX Sherry Hogshead #2689 Infrequent Flyers 47.1%ABV 15ml/30ml

Bowmore 25y/o 1997 PX Sherry Hogshead #2689 Infrequent Flyers 47.1%ABV 15ml/30ml

No reviews

Regular price From $31.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price From $31.00 AUD
Unit price per
Ardbeg 17y/o 'The Legend Returns' 40%ABV 30ML

Ardbeg 17y/o 'The Legend Returns' 40%ABV 30ML

No reviews

Regular price $22.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $22.00 AUD
Unit price per
Bruichladdich 24y/o Black Art 11.1 44.2%ABV 30ml

Bruichladdich 24y/o Black Art 11.1 44.2%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price From $23.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price From $23.00 AUD
Unit price per
Octomore 15.2 57.9%ABV 30ml

Octomore 15.2 57.9%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $23.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $23.00 AUD
Unit price per
Octomore 15.1 59.1%ABV 30ml

Sold out

Octomore 15.1 59.1%ABV 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $21.50 AUD

Regular price Sale price $21.50 AUD
Unit price per

Sold out
Lochindaal 12y/o Barrel#4310 Lucky Choice 53.1%abv 30ml

Lochindaal 12y/o Barrel#4310 Lucky Choice 53.1%abv 30ml

No reviews

Regular price From $19.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price From $19.00 AUD
Unit price per
Caol Ila 11y/o 2013 'Retrofuturism' Club Qing 52.9%abv 30ml

Caol Ila 11y/o 2013 'Retrofuturism' Club Qing 52.9%abv 30ml

No reviews

Regular price $19.00 AUD

Regular price Sale price $19.00 AUD
Unit price per

Let customers speak for us

from 177 reviews

Thick and juicy!

Will always love this drop, it’s one of the more syrupy Macallans I’ve tried and definitely smooth and full of flavour!

Tyler

09/06/2025

Speyside 15y/o 2009 (Macallan) 1st Fill & Refill Sherry Butts Small Batch #18 Signatory Vintage 48.2%abv 30ml

Speyside 15y/o 2009 (Macallan) 1st Fill & Refill Sherry Butts Small Batch #18 Signatory Vintage 48.2%abv 30ml

Sweet and sensitive, dry with summer fruits.

Lovely drop this, I revisit it when I can. Not a power punch but quality liquid and beautiful flavour!

Tyler

09/06/2025

Glenfiddich Snow Phoenix 47.6%ABV 15ml / 30ml

Glenfiddich Snow Phoenix 47.6%ABV 15ml / 30ml

Ben Nevis 10y/o Australian Whisky Icons - The Elysian Bar The WhiskySponge 57.1%ABV 30ml

Christopher O'Hara

07/26/2025

Ben Nevis 10y/o Australian Whisky Icons - The Elysian Bar The WhiskySponge 57.1%ABV 30ml

Ben Nevis 10y/o Australian Whisky Icons - The Elysian Bar The WhiskySponge 57.1%ABV 30ml

Perfect

That dream balance/blend of chewy islay peat and cask sweetness and influence. What Laga 16 used to be, but better (and 48%!).

Josh G

07/21/2025

Laphroaig Lore 48%ABV 30ml

Laphroaig Lore 48%ABV 30ml

Leaves you wanting more!!

Lovely rich flavour!

Tyler

07/14/2025

Glenallachie 15y/o 46%ABV 30ml

Glenallachie 15y/o 46%ABV 30ml

Excellent than you!!

Beautiful, deep, you’ll never forget it !!

Tyler

07/14/2025

Bunnahabhain Staoisha 2013 1st Fill PX Sherry Hogshead Germany exclusive Whisky Sponge 53.8%abv 30ml

Bunnahabhain Staoisha 2013 1st Fill PX Sherry Hogshead Germany exclusive Whisky Sponge 53.8%abv 30ml

Excellent thank you!

Becoming a new fan of Bunnahabhain!

Tyler

07/14/2025

Bunnahabhain 14y/o First Fill Sherry Cask#358 Gordon & MacPhail 57.6%abv 30ml

Bunnahabhain 14y/o First Fill Sherry Cask#358 Gordon & MacPhail 57.6%abv 30ml

fantastic bonfire

Nose: A rich herbal aroma intertwined with bonfire smoke, evoking imagery of a seaside campfire. Notes of sea salt, struck matches, and subtle roasted orange peel linger behind the smoky veil.

Palate: Medium to full-bodied with a distinct oily texture. The high proof delivers a robust entry, blending sweet spices with peat, accented by a faint trace of sulfur.

Finish: Long and warming, with persistent ashy smoke and briny sea breeze. Hints of matchstick and a delicate iodine note round it out.

With Water: The aroma reveals pronounced wet sea salt and brine, with the smokiness softening into a rounder profile. Vanilla and oak emerge prominently. On the palate, the sweetness persists, with the peat becoming less intense, giving way to caramelized oak and fruit notes.

DYC

07/14/2025

Beach Bonfire Elements of Islay Blended Malt 57.2%ABV 30ml

Beach Bonfire Elements of Islay Blended Malt 57.2%ABV 30ml

Invergordon 1986 EVWC

A gentle giant. This old grain whisky doesn’t try to shout, but it has plenty to say if you’re listening. A soft, elegant dram with aged sherry cask influence, balancing fruit, leather, oak, and just a whisper of tobacco. If you’re chasing subtle complexity over brute strength, this hits the mark.

James Williamson

07/13/2025

Invergordon 37y/o 1986 Refill Sherry Butt East Village Whisky Co. Single Grain Whisky 48.7%ABV 30ml

Invergordon 37y/o 1986 Refill Sherry Butt East Village Whisky Co. Single Grain Whisky 48.7%ABV 30ml

Longrow Red 11y/o Cabernet Sauvignon Cask 52.1%ABV 30ml

Michael Allen

05/30/2025

Longrow Red 11y/o Cabernet Sauvignon Cask 52.1%ABV 30ml

Longrow Red 11y/o Cabernet Sauvignon Cask 52.1%ABV 30ml

Beautiful

We had a blinded whisky testing of 10 unpeated whisky and Springbank won the comp.
Excellent: very smooth, good balance and not too strong.

Zarko Lepojevic

05/27/2025

Springbank 18y/o (2024) 46%ABV 30ml

Springbank 18y/o (2024) 46%ABV 30ml

Great product

I ordered a red gum and stringybark smoked single malt combo and loved being able to compare the pair. It was awesome. Thanks Horny Pony!

J G

05/26/2025

Archie Rose Heritage Red Gum Cask Single Malt Whisky 46%ABV 30ml

Archie Rose Heritage Red Gum Cask Single Malt Whisky 46%ABV 30ml

Delicious

Daniella Brusac Davis

05/23/2025

Bruichladdich 29y/o Black Art 10.1 45.1%ABV 15ml / 30ml

Bruichladdich 29y/o Black Art 10.1 45.1%ABV 15ml / 30ml

Waubs Harbour Kelp Revival 46%ABV 30ml

jason garner

05/20/2025

Waubs Harbour Kelp Revival 46%ABV 30ml

Waubs Harbour Kelp Revival 46%ABV 30ml

A Sophisticated Dessert

A complex aged nose. Leather, dark chocolate mousse, dehydrated raspberries, canned peaches, and fermentation funk. Dark with tropical notes that bring it to life. To taste, mandarin syrup with spices; cloves and cinnamon. There’s an incense smokiness to the dram as well, bringing forward more rose and berry notes. A delightful example of an aged whisky, but potentially one that can be sourced for a slightly cheaper price. Claims of uniqueness can be a touch overrated, but still worth the experience.

Whisky Soliloquist

04/19/2025

Millburn 23y/o 1981 Jack Wiebers Old Train Line 61.5%ABV 15ml/30ml

Millburn 23y/o 1981 Jack Wiebers Old Train Line 61.5%ABV 15ml/30ml